Accessibility tools

Scam warnings hit record levels as DWP consults on amendments to transfer regulations

Scam warnings hit record levels as DWP consults on amendments to transfer regulations

29 Oct 2026

Pension scam warning flags hit a record high over the past quarter, with XPS's Scam Flag Index for September showing 99% of cases reviewed raised at least one warning flag.

This comes as the DWP has recently consulted on amendments to the pension transfer regulations, with a view to strengthen their effectiveness and increase clarity of the conditions. In general, XPS welcomes the proposed changes, which are expected to address some of the identified operational issues in the regulations, and support legitimate transfer activity.

The proposed removal of the overseas investment flag will have a significant impact on otherwise low risk transfers, and had this flag been removed in September 2026, over 40% fewer cases would have raised a scam warning flag, with the relative position being similar across the quarter. The removal of this flag may result in greater focus on other areas of genuine risk to transferring members.

However, the potential widening of the First Condition to include schemes that trustees decide are ‘reputable’ could result in over 75% of transfers being processed without assessment against the defined scam warning flags. XPS believes this could be challenging for trustees, so there should be clear guidance on how to decide whether a scheme is ‘reputable’, including minimum governance and review obligations for those schemes defined as ‘reputable '.

The proposed changes are a positive step towards a more proportionate transfer regime, but clear guidance will be critical to ensure appropriate trustee decision-making and continued protection against pension scams.

Meanwhile, XPS’s Transfer Activity Index rebounded to 0.24% in September 2026, equivalent to an annualised rate of 24 in every 1,000 members transferring their benefits to alternative arrangements, matching the 2026 high to-date. This followed index lows in the first two months of the quarter

The rebound shows that demand for pension transfers remains resilient despite persistently high gilt yields and falling transfer values in recent years. It may also signal growing confidence among members weighing up their retirement options, alongside continued appetite for greater flexibility.

XPS's Transfer Value Index fell by ~2.6% over Q3 2026, ending September at £135,000. Rising long-term gilt yields drove this decline, although higher long-term inflation expectations partially offset the impact.

Helen Cavanagh, Senior Consultant, XPS Group, said:

“Q3 2026 painted a mixed picture for pension transfers. Despite falling transfer values, activity rebounded to its highest level since early-2025, suggesting members still value the flexibility and control offered by transferring to alternative retirement arrangements.

The introduction of a more proportionate transfer regime as proposed in the DWP consultation is welcomed, particularly where it removes unnecessary barriers to legitimate member choices. However, any expansion of the First Condition must be supported by clear criteria and governance expectations for trustee decision making on what classes as a ‘reputable’ scheme.”

Chart 1 - XPS Transfer Value Index

 

Chart 2 - XPS Transfer Activity Index

 

Chart 3 – XPS Scam Flag Index

Source: XPS Group – All data is at the end of each month.

Notes:

XPS Transfer Watch is part of XPSArena, a free to access destination for learning support and development for people in pensions. Users will be able to scrutinise the latest data contributing to the headline Scam Flag Index, with filters available to compare warning flag prevalence over time and by several demographic groupings.

Back to press releases
  • Register for events
  • Join our mailing list
Register for events

We enjoy hosting a wide range of events for pension scheme trustees, corporate sponsors, independent trustees, and pensions professionals.

Full list of upcoming events

Join our mailing list

Keep up to date with our latest news and views including pension briefings, XPS insights, reports and event invitations.

Sign up